Archive for the ‘Monitoring Reviews’ Category

Virtual Tour Spring 2017

with 4 comments

 
Update on New Housing Types and Amenity Sites

 
Norquay Village Neighbourhood Centre is the name given by the City of Vancouver to an East Vancouver area of approximately 1.5 square kilometers. Norquay lies primarily in the Renfrew-Collingwood neighbourhood of Vancouver, with a small western portion in the Kensington-Cedar Cottage neighbourhood.

The Norquay Plan was developed to help carry out the intent of Vancouver’s CityPlan. Norquay remains the only area in Vancouver to be completely planned as a neighbourhood centre.

This review looks at the implementation of the Norquay Plan since it was approved by Vancouver City Council in November 2010.

 
Section A — Development
 
1 of 6 — Single Family Houses
 
2 of 6 — Duplexes
 
3 of 6 — Small House / Duplex Zone (RT-11)
 
4 of 6 — Rowhouse / Stacked Townhouse Zone (RM-7)
 
5 of 6 — Four-Storey Apartment Zone (RM-9A)
 
6 of 6 — Kingsway Rezoning Area
 
Section B — Amenities and Services
 
1 of 6 — Community Facility with Indoor and Outdoor Space
 
2 of 6 — Ravine Way
 
3 of 6 — Parks
 
4 of 6 — Childcare
 
5 of 6 — Transportation
 
6 of 6 — Affordable Housing
 


 

 
Section A — Development — Introduction

Norquay is the second area in Vancouver to have all of its RS-1 zoned single family homes — a total of 1912 — rezoned to include new low-density housing forms.

In March 2013 zoning regulations were approved for two new residential zones: RT-11 (small house/duplex) and RM-7 (rowhouse/stacked townhouse).

Also in 2013 a rezoning policy was established for a 4-storey apartment transition zone, most of it paralleling Kingsway. In December 2016 this policy was replaced by the RM-9A (4-storey apartment) zone.

A rezoning policy for the Kingsway Rezoning Area sets a base height of 8-10 storeys, with up to 16 storeys on special sites.

 

 

Norquay Village Zoning Map


 
 

 
1 of 6 — Single Family Houses

A single family dwelling (with or without a laneway house and/or a secondary suite) may be built outright on a single parcel in any residential zone in Norquay, following the provisions of RS-1 zoning. Eye on Norquay has counted 17 single family houses completed or under construction since 2013, 9 with a laneway house. None of these houses appear to have been advertised for sale. It seems probable that most or all of them are being built by existing owners.


 
 

 
2 of 6 — Duplexes

A duplex (with or without a secondary suite) may be built outright on a single parcel in the RT-11 and the RM-7 zones. Eye on Norquay has counted 52 duplexes completed or under construction on single parcels since 2013. Allowable FSR is 0.75. Construction began on approximately 40 of these in 2014 and 2015, with fewer than 10 new starts in 2016.

 
IMG_7837
 
     2457/2459 Brock Street
 
On narrow, deep lots the duplexes are front and back. Designs are fairly similar and generally acceptable.

 
IMG_7832
 
     2735/2737 Duke Street
 
Front doors of both the front and back units must face the street. Roofs must be pitched.

 
IMG_7816
 
     5444/5446 Clarendon Street
 
On wider, shallow lots the duplexes are side by side.

 
IMG_7829
 
     2795/2799 Horley Street
 
This duplex is situated on a corner lot.

 
IMG_7827
 
     4816/4818 Earles Street
 
There is considerable variation in the form of side by side duplexes as well as in the quality of construction.
 


 
 

 
3 of 6 — Small House / Duplex Zone (RT-11)

More than 900 parcels were rezoned to RT-11/RT-11N under the Norquay Plan. Most of these parcels are larger lots situated in the northwestern, northeastern, and southern edges of Norquay. The number of permitted buildings depends on the size and the location of the site. Allowable FSR for a conditional application is 0.85.

So far there have been 19 conditional RT-11 applications posted on the City of Vancouver web site, mostly in 2014 and 2015.

 

 
     4515/4519 Nanaimo Street
 
On a standard 33 x 122 ft. lot, a front and back duplex is allowed …

 

 
     4523 Nanaimo Street
 
… together with a laneway house. This site backs onto Brock Park. The colours are attractive.

 
IMG_9301-640
 
     5603/5613 Rhodes Street
 
This development is on a corner lot. The duplex faces Rhodes Street.

 

 
     2746 East 40th Avenue
 
The laneway house fronts on East 40th Avenue.

 
IMG_9359-640
 
     2355/2357 East 41st Avenue — 1 of 3
 
On this large lot, a duplex is built at the front of the lot …

 

 
     2353/2355/2357/2359 East 41st Avenue — 2 of 3
 
… and a laneway house at the back of the lot. An infill house (approximately 1500 sq. ft.) is situated in the middle.

 

 
     2353/2355/2357/2359 East 41st Avenue — 3 of 3
 
The zoning allows for a minimum separation between the buildings of only 8 feet. Two developments with this configuration have been built in Norquay and both were first marketed in early 2016. The laneway houses seem to have sold quickly. The duplexes took much longer to sell, and one of the four duplex units is still an active listing. Neither of the infill houses in the centre of the developments has been sold.

 

 
     2293 East 37th Avenue
 
Another possible development scenario for larger sites in RT-11 is two duplexes. This project is under construction on a large corner lot at Nanaimo Street and East 37th Avenue.

 

 
     2293 East 37th Avenue
 
The smaller duplex fronts on East 37th Avenue.

 

 
     5432 Rhodes Street
 
A two lot assembly permits 4 small houses, two at the front of the lot and two at the back.

 

 
     5432 Rhodes Street
 
Parking for all units is attached. This means that much of the open space is taken up by driveways to access the units at the front of the site.

 
IMG_9272-640
 
     2885 East 41st Avenue — 1 of 4
 
(This site includes 2885, 2887 and 2889 East 41st Avenue; 5681, 5683, 5685, 5687, and 5689 Killarney Street.) This development includes 8 units: a cluster of 6 small houses of 1230-1557 sq. ft. and 2 duplex units. It is situated on a self-contained site on the northwest corner of East 41st Avenue and Killarney Streets. To the west is Earles Park and to the north is a similar development (see below). Units in this development were marketed in late 2015 and sold very quickly.

 

 
     2885 East 41st Avenue — 2 of 4
 
This photo shows one of the small houses.

 

 
     2885 East 41st Avenue — 3 of 4
 
Although these houses are only 8 feet apart, they are carefully situated so that windows do not line up with the windows of the house next door. This was possible because the developer built only 8 units rather than the allowed 9 units.

 
IMG_9276-640
 
     2885 East 41st Avenue — 4 of 4
 
Parking is in garages or open parking spaces at the rear of the site.

 

 
     5653 Killarney Street
 
This project is currently under construction. It is located beside the development described above at 2885 East 41st Avenue, and consists of 7 units: 2 duplexes and 3 small houses. The two projects were designed by the same architect, although built by different developers. The sites are designed so that there is a small shared courtyard in the centre. A private school is situated directly north of this site.


 
 

 
4 of 6 — Rowhouse / Stacked Townhouse Zone (RM-7)

More than 700 parcels were rezoned to RM-7/RM-7N under the Norquay Plan. Most of these parcels are situated near the centre of Norquay, fairly close to Kingsway. Typical stacked townhouse units in this zone are to be 1200 sq. ft. in area. The width of rowhouses is to be 12 ft. clear (wall-to-wall interior). Parking is on open parking spaces, 2 for every 3 units. Allowable FSR is 1.2 for assembled sites or larger lots, and 0.9 for smaller single lots.

During the planning process, residents expressed a strong preference for traditional rowhouses to be the dominant low density housing form for Norquay. The rowhouse zone and the stacked townhouse zone were described as separate zones in the Norquay Plan. The two were conflated when the zoning regulations were written in 2013.

So far there have been 22 RM-7 applications posted on the City of Vancouver web site, mostly in 2015 and 2016. Only 2 of these applications have been for rowhouse developments.

 

 
     4573/4575/4577 Slocan Street — 1 of 6
 
This project is the first RM-7 project to be completed. It consists of 18 stacked townhouse units in three 4-level sixplexes on an assembled 132 ft. x 110 ft. site. There are 6 “garden” units on the lowest level, 6 units on the main floor, and 6 two-level units on the upper floors. The “garden” units contain lock-off units. The units are well laid out, but the usable living room space is very small.

To access the upper level units, a single stairway with a landing at the third level runs from the ground level entrance to the fourth floor bedroom.

The developer presold some of the units on the lower and the main floors in 2015. On multiple recent occasions, we have observed lower and main floor units being marketed without advertised open house to sizeable groups of what looked like offshore investors. The upper 6 units are currently being advertised with open houses, and by March 3 one of these 1270 sq. ft. units had sold. Asking price is $869,000.

 

 
     4573/4575/4577 Slocan Street — 2 of 6
 
Ground level open space behind the buildings is taken up with infrastructure: parking spaces (2 for every 3 units), garbage bins …

 

 
     4573/4575/4577 Slocan Street — 3 of 6
 
… an electrical transformer, and bike lockers. The small red buildings house 30 of the required 42 bike lockers. The requirement for 2.25 bike lockers per unit applies only in the RM-7 zones; the standard requirement in all other RM zones is 1.25 per unit.

 

 
     4573/4575/4577 Slocan Street — 4 of 6
 
Twelve bike lockers are housed behind the white doors under the front stairs.

 

 
     4573/4575/4577 Slocan Street — 5 of 6
 
Canada Post requires a bank of letter boxes for these units. This structure has been inappropriately placed in the centre of the front yard.

 

 
     4573/4575/4577 Slocan Street — 6 of 6
 
Private open space has been provided in the form of 6 ft. wide balconies and porches for the main floor and upper level units. The lower “garden” units, which also contain the lock-off suites for this development, have only very small and dark patios.

 

 
     5178 Chambers Street
 
An 11-unit development in two sixplexes is under construction.

 

 
     5189 Clarendon Street
 
This 3-unit development is on a single 44 ft. x 89 ft. corner lot. All units are on three levels. Two units front on Clarendon Street and one unit fronts on East 37th Avenue. This project includes two garages and one open parking space.

 

 
     2759 Duke Street
 
These four traditional rowhouses of approximately 2000 sq. ft. are the only ones built in Norquay so far. They are on an assembled 66 ft. x 110 ft. site. Parking for rowhouses is one space per unit in garages at the back of the site.

A second similar application on the same street by the same developer has been approved. However, that site is currently being advertised for sale.
 


 
 

 
5 of 6 — Four-Storey Apartment Zone (RM-9A)

Approximately 250 parcels were rezoned to RM-9A/RM/9AN under the Norquay Plan. Most of these parcels are located within the half block immediately adjoining the Kingsway Rezoning Policy Area. Smaller areas of RM-9 zoning are found on Wales Street and on Rhodes Street across from Norquay Park, and on Earles Street immediately north of the Purdy’s factory.

The buildings in this zone are to be “alphabet-shaped” with more than 4 corner apartments. They should have a 26-ft. wide entry courtyard. On very deep sites stacked townhouses may be built behind the apartment building, separated by a 24 ft. wide “garden courtyard.” All parking is underground. Minimum frontage of 42 ft. is required. Allowable FSR is 1.2 with a minimum frontage of 42 ft., 1.5 with a minimum frontage of 50 ft., and 2.0 with a minimum frontage of 90 ft. They are intended to be “family housing,” with most of the units including 2 or 3 bedrooms. A typical unit is specified as 800 sq. ft. in area.

Four applications have been approved in the RM-9A zone, but construction has not yet begun on any of them. All of the sites are 3 or 4 lot assemblies. One additional small project was built on a single lot in 2012, before any regulations were written for this zone.

 

 
     2328 Galt Street
 
This site was rezoned for a 28-unit Rental 100 development under the Apartment Transition Area Rezoning Policy approved in May 2013. Most units were 2-bedroom. The site has recently been resold.

 

 
     4869 Slocan Street
 
This project has 44 units including 10 3-bedroom units. 24 2-bedroom units, and 6 1-bedroom units.

 

 
     2688 Duke Street
 
This project has 23 units, including 5 3-bedroom units, 10 2-bedroom units, and 8 1-bedroom units.

 

 
     4888 Slocan Street
 
This project has 53 units, 37 in an apartment building at the front of the site and 16 in stacked townhouse units at the rear of the site. There are 28 3-bedroom units and 25 2-bedroom units.

 

 
     2298 Galt Street
 
This 4-unit project is situated on a single lot. It consists of two side by side duplex buildings, one at the front of the site and one at the rear, separated by a garden courtyard. Under RM-9A zoning, construction of similar projects on a single lot will be restricted to orphan lots.
 


 
 

 
6 of 6 — Kingsway Rezoning Area

The Norquay Plan defines base height of buildings along Kingsway as 8-10 storeys. Three sites on the north side of Kingsway are allowed 12 storeys, and development there is to incorporate pedestrian connections to break up the very long blocks. Two large sites at either end of Norquay are allowed 14 storeys, and development there is to incorporate plazas of 6000-8000 sq. ft. One site (the 2400 Motel) is allowed one 16-storey tower and one 12-storey tower, and development there is to incorporate 15,000 sq. ft. of new indoor community space, a 20,000 sq. ft. outdoor community gathering space, and a smaller public plaza.

 

 
     2300 Kingsway — 1 of 2
 
This site-specific rezoning was approved in 2006, just before the Norquay Village Neighbourhood Centre planning process began. It consists of 342 residential units, most of them studio or 1 bedroom units, in one 22-storey tower and two 7-storey buildings.

 

 
     2300 Kingsway — 2 of 2
 
Two low-rise buildings on this site include townhouses (shown here) and a daycare.

 

 
     2689 Kingsway
 
This project consists of 129 residential units in two buildings. A 12-storey tower is separated from a 4-storey building by a 40 ft. wide pedestrian connection, which will function as the entrance to Ravine Way. (See further detail on Ravine Way below under Amenities.) The brick finish is in line with the strong preference expressed by Norquay residents for a brick finish on buildings on Kingsway.

 

 
     2220 Kingsway — 1 of 3
 
This massive project consists of more than four hundred 1, 2 or 3 bedroom units in three 14-storey towers and a 5-storey building on Kingsway. These buildings enclose a courtyard with an outdoor swimming pool, situated on the third storey in the centre of the site. The entire first and second storeys occupy a podium that covers most of the 2.3 acre site. Construction is to be completed in 2017.

 

 
     2220 Kingsway — 2 of 3
 
The 4700 sq. ft. open space in front of the grocery store entrance at the corner of Kingsway and Gladstone is defined as the “plaza.”

 

 
     2220 Kingsway — 3 of 3
 
The corner of 30th Avenue and Kingsway was to be the site of a 7500 sq. ft. “park” — but much of this space has been reclaimed to function as an outdoor seating area for the adjacent dim sum restaurant.

 

 
     2395 Kingsway — 1 of 2
 
This project will consist of 126 units with 1, 2, or 3 bedrooms in a 12-storey tower flanked by 4-storey buildings.

 

 
     2395 Kingsway — 2 of 2
 
A pedestrian connection runs through the site. The bridge over the connection was later removed from the design.

 

 
     2751 Kingsway
 
The site of Harvey’s Furniture and Appliances at 2751 Kingsway was sold recently.

 
IMG_8946-648
 
     2768 Kingsway
 
This assembled site is currently for sale.



 
 

 
Section B — Amenities and Services

 
New development brings population growth, and an increased population requires increased amenities and services. The Renfrew-Collingwood Community Vision made proposals for any new housing form “conditional … on an increase in community facilities and programs needed to serve any population growth generated by the new housing type.” (p. 31) The Norquay Plan states that “As the Norquay Village Neighbourhood Centre grows and evolves over time, new amenities and facilities will be needed to ensure the continued livability and desirability of the area.” (p. 70)

The Norquay Public Realm and Transportation Improvements Plan was approved as part of the Norquay Plan in 2010. The Norquay Village Public Benefits Strategy was approved in May 2013. The Norquay Village Public Realm Plan was released in April 2016. These documents provide more detail about the amenities and services that are to be provided as the population grows.

Development is taking place rapidly in Norquay, especially along Kingsway. Projects that have been completed, are currently under construction, or are in the application/permitting stage are already bringing more than 2000 new residents to our neighbourhood. This number amounts to 40% of the new residents that are expected to be living in Norquay by 2040.

But almost no progress has been made on delivery of the amenities and services promised by the Norquay Plan.


 
 

 
1 of 6 — Community Facility with Indoor and Outdoor Space

 
The Norquay Plan mandates 15,000 sq. ft. of new indoor community space and 20,000 sq. ft. of outdoor space, as well as a smaller plaza, as part of the redevelopment of the 3.5 acre site currently occupied by the 2400 Motel. The new development is expected to include 100 units of non-market housing as well as 400 units of market housing.

 

 

This community space was rated the number one amenity choice of Norquay residents. Our neighbourhood has no community centre or neighbourhood house, no library, no skating rink or swimming pool. Gladstone High School, whose catchment area includes most of Norquay, has been considered for closure. The need for community space in Norquay is urgent.

The City of Vancouver already owns the 2400 Motel. We encourage the City to proceed as quickly as possible with redevelopment of this site to deliver our most essential amenity.


 
 

 
2 of 6 — Ravine Way

 
Ravine Way is the name given to a proposed linear park that would follow the undergrounded portion of Still Creek that flows through a culvert from Norquay Park to Slocan Park. Most of the properties that would be incorporated into the park are already owned by the City of Vancouver, but City social agencies currently lease purpose-built buildings on some of these properties. Two of the properties currently function as a community garden and a community orchard. Two properties still need to be acquired.

 

 

This amenity was rated the number two choice by Norquay residents, even though the City of Vancouver describes Ravine Way as a “long-term vision.”

Two ongoing concerns are (a) the amount of land that will be allocated to Ravine Way, and (b) the temporary use of the land until assembly is completed. The Norquay Public Benefits Strategy states: “Prior to completion of the entire park route, sections would function as pocket parks, mid-block connections or … community gardens.” (p. 10) We encourage the City to allocate all of the land it now owns along Ravine Way to the proposed park, and to repurpose the sites for public use as leases expire.


 
 

 
3 of 6 — Parks

 
Norquay encompasses four parks: Norquay Park, General Brock Park, Earles Park, and Slocan Park..

Increasing densification does more than increase the number of residents who use neighbourhood parks. It also transfers many activities that have traditionally taken place in private backyards to these parks. Norquay’s new housing forms leave very little room for ground level open space on the property. Neighbourhood parks are becoming the “shared backyard” where residents are looking to play, exercise, garden, and socialize.

The new development along Kingsway is having a significant impact on Norquay Park and General Brock Park. The areas around Earles Park and Slocan Park have experienced much less densification at this stage.

 
Norquay Park

 

 

 
This park received a substantial upgrade in 2011. The Park Board’s initial $300,000 budget was supplemented by a $500,000 grant of federal stimulus money for “shovel ready” projects. This made possible construction of a new playground, a basketball court, a water park and picnic tables.

 
General Brock Park

 

 

The renewal of General Brock Park was the number three amenity choice of Norquay residents, and is identified as a priority in the Public Benefits Strategy.

Several large developments are being built close to this park: 2300 Kingsway (completed), 2239 Kingsway (completed), 2220 Kingsway (under construction), 2395 Kingsway (approved), 2153 Kingsway (application submitted).

The Park Board has begun to assemble four adjacent properties on Wenonah Street to expand this park and to make it more visible. We anticipate funding for significant renovation under the 2019-2022 Capital Plan.


 
 

 
4 of 6 — Childcare

 
Redevelopment of 2300 Kingsway included the construction of 37 childcare spaces.


 
 

 
5 of 6 — Transportation

 
The Clarendon Connector, a one-block long extension of Clarendon Street that joins East 33rd Avenue and East 34th Avenue, has been completed. This project was underway prior to development of the Norquay Plan.

Two new traffic signals have been installed on Kingsway near Norquay Park. A third signal has been installed at the intersection of East 33rd Avenue and Gladstone Street, but is not yet activated.

Kingsway streetscape improvements include a new centre median (in five sections), several curb bulges on intersecting streets, new lighting, and new median and boulevard street trees. Approximately half of the street trees in the median have died and been removed, but they have not yet been replaced.

A few short sections of new sidewalk have been installed. There are still numerous locations in Norquay where no sidewalk exists on either side of the street.


 
 

 
6 of 6 — Affordable Housing

 
The Norquay Public Benefits Strategy targets achieving 100 units of non-market housing on the 2400 Motel site when it is redeveloped.

The new housing forms introduced by the Norquay Plan were expected to provide more affordable housing for families. The steep increase in Vancouver land prices since 2010 has made this goal very difficult to achieve. Duplex units are currently listed at $1.2 to $1.4 million, and a stacked townhouse unit of 1270 sq. ft. is listed at $869,000.

One Rental 100 project has been approved in Norquay. That property at 2328 Galt Street has just been resold. Lock-off suites in the new housing forms are expected to produce additional rental accommodation.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Written by eyeonnorquay

13 March 2017 at 11:35 am

Small House / Duplex 2013-2016

leave a comment »

 
Monitoring the Norquay Plan — Report No. 2 (May 2016)

RT-11 / RT-11N Zone

 
A separate posting of 19 photos of new Norquay dwellings taken in spring 2016 accompanies this evaluation.

 
Introduction

This second overall review of the 2010-2013 Norquay Plan continues looking at residential areas, and focuses on the new small house/duplex housing type. See note appended below on context for brief description of the Norquay Plan and a listing of aspects yet to be reviewed by Eye on Norquay. The City of Vancouver failed to include in the Norquay Plan any mandate for formal review of the effects and consequences of the mass rezoning.

 
What Does the Zoning Allow?

The RT-11 (Small House/Duplex) and RT-11N zones cover 937 properties in Norquay (2015 figures from City of Vancouver). See the map at the end of this post for properties included in this zone. The RT-11N portion of the zoning lies next to arterial streets and has special noise mitigation requirements; otherwise, regulations are the same as for RT-11.

If only a single family house is built on one lot, development is outright. A laneway house is permitted, but is subject to a short conditional review. If only a duplex is built on one lot, development is outright.

A developer who wants to build several small houses, more than one duplex, or a combination of the small house and duplex housing forms in the RT-11 zone must submit a conditional (rather than outright) development application to the City of Vancouver (CoV). The developer begins by consulting informally with CoV staff. When a formal application is submitted, a sign is posted on the property and a notification letter is sent to nearby neighbours. The application is posted on CoV’s Development Applications web site so that the public has an opportunity to examine it and submit comments.

After reviewing the application and the comments that have been received, staff set conditions that the developer must meet before final approval is granted for the project. Comments from the public are important because they can influence these conditions.

The number of permitted buildings depends on the size and the location of the site involved.
(1) If a pre-1940 character house is being retained, an infill one-family or two-family dwelling may be possible.
(2) If a site is next to a park or school site, if the site is a corner site, or if the site is a double fronting site, a small one-family dwelling may be built in addition to a new or existing single family house or duplex.
(3) On larger sites, a combination of small house and duplex housing forms is possible.

Secondary suites are permitted on all sites. Lock-off units may be permitted in larger developments.

The floor space ratio (FSR) is .60 for a single family house, .75 for a site with only a duplex, and .85 for larger developments. The parking requirement is one space per unit. Parking is usually at the lane, in covered garages or (on larger sites) in a combination of garages, carports, and/or surface parking. There is no separate storage required, but it can be provided.for bicycles. Under RT-11 zoning, multiple dwellings on a single site may be strata-titled.

The 2013 regulations and guidelines that govern development in RT-11 can be found at:

http://former.vancouver.ca/commsvcs/BYLAWS/zoning/RT-11&%20RT-11N.pdf
http://former.vancouver.ca/commsvcs/guidelines/R029.pdf

 
What Is Being Built?

Since 2013, and as of May 2016, the City of Vancouver has posted on its web site fifteen RT-11 development applications, involving nineteen properties. Eight of these fifteen applications have been submitted by the architecture firm Fuho Design. The first three projects have been completed and are now occupied. Four others are nearing completion. Two have been started recently. Construction has not yet begun on the other six, some of which may still be awaiting approval. Units in all of these developments are strata-titled.

A small house behind a duplex generally takes the form of a laneway house containing a covered garage for two or three cars. On two sites consisting of single long lots, a second small house has been built between the duplex and the laneway house.

The applications can be categorized as follows:

       Duplex + one small house                        7
       Duplex + two small houses                       2
       Two duplexes                                    2
       Duplex + cluster of small houses *              2
       Cluster of small houses *                       1
       Retention of heritage house + 4 duplexes *      1

       [* indicates assembled sites]

 
The range of unit sizes is:

       Form                              Square Footage    Sq Ft Avg

       Duplexes                          1106-2064         1618
       Small houses behind a duplex       690-1560         1024 
       Small houses in cluster           1244-1556         1353

 
The observed asking-price ranges are:

       Duplexes                                      $759,000 - $1,225,000
       Small houses behind a duplex (single lot)     $558,000 -   $998,000
       Small houses in clusters                      $839,000 -   $899,000

 
Photos of seven RT-11 developments newly completed or almost completed as of May 2016 can be viewed in a separate posting, along with prices and square footages where available.

 
Commentary

1.  The restricted locations for small houses built on standard lots (corner sites, sites that abut a school or park, or double-fronting sites) appear to work well. These locations feel much more “open” than mid-block locations do.

2.  The small house/duplex developments at Killarney Street and East 41st Avenue are well located on a fairly isolated corner. They are bordered on three sides by a school, a park, and East 41st Avenue.

3.  The palette of colours for building exteriors in several developments (dark green, cherry red, blue, yellow) is a welcome change from the standard neutral shades used in most new construction.

4.  Some of the large duplexes appear massive, especially where they are built on upward sloping sites (e.g. those on the east side of Dundee Street). The base grade on these sites is well above the street.

5.  The two sites where two small houses have been built on a single large lot behind a duplex appear very crowded. The 8-foot separation between the buildings leaves very little room for open space.

 
Context

Note:  Subsequent monitoring reports are anticipated for

       RM-7 (Rowhouse/Stacked Townhouse) Zone
       Transition Zone
       Kingsway Development
       Kingsway Public Realm
       Public Benefits
       Comprehensive Analysis

 

In the fall of 2010, Vancouver City Council adopted the Norquay Village Neighbourhood Centre Plan. The plan lays out a “roadmap forward” that is supposed to guide development in Norquay for the next 30 years.

In the spring of 2013, Vancouver City Council adopted new zoning schedules for Norquay. Most of the residential area was rezoned to RT-11 (small house/duplex) or RM-7 (rowhouse/stacked townhouse). A rezoning policy was put in place for the Transition zone (four storey apartments) immediately behind Kingsway.

Specifications for development along Kingsway are part of the 2010 Norquay Plan.

 
norqmap-640
 
     Norquay Village Zoning Map
 

Council also adopted a Public Benefits Strategy and Apartment Transition Area Rezoning Policy for Norquay in spring 2013. This policy identifies the key amenities and services that Norquay can expect to accompany development, and suggests how they should be funded. To date, nothing has been delivered.

Development has begun. The City of Vancouver has no formal process for monitoring the implementation of the Norquay Plan. This series of postings will examine how the Norquay Plan of 2010, the subsequent new zoning schedules of 2013, and the Public Benefits Strategy are being implemented.

 
See also:
Duplexes 2013-2015
Monitoring the Norquay Plan — Report No. 1 (March 2015)
https://eyeonnorquay.wordpress.com/2015/03/22/duplexes-2013-2015/
 

Written by eyeonnorquay

30 May 2016 at 3:51 pm

Small House / Duplex Photos

leave a comment »

 
Seven New Small House/Duplex Developments – 19 Photos

 
The photos below complement a review of small house/duplex development in the RT-11 zone built since implementation of Norquay Plan zoning in spring 2013. (Half-duplex and small house asking price and sq ft data is given as discovered, with no specification attempted for particular side or sub-unit.)

 



 
Duplex + 1 Small House

 
     4514 Nanaimo Street (old address)
     This development backs onto Brock Park.

 
IMG_9317-640
 
     Photo 1 of 19 — 4515/4519 Nanaimo Street — Duplex $899,000 — 1460 sq ft
 

 
IMG_9318-640
 
     Photo 2 of 19 — 45?? Nanaimo Street — Small house (attached garage) — $558,000 — 678 sq ft
 

 
     2466 East 37th Avenue (old address)
     This development is beside Cunningham School.

 
IMG_9308-640
 
     Photo 3 of 19 — 2466 East 37th Avenue — Duplex — $??? — 1650 sq ft
 

 
IMG_9310-640
 
     Photo 4 of 19 — 24?? — Small house (attached garage) — $??? — 800 sq ft
 

 
     5607 Rhodes Street (old address)
     This development is on a corner lot.

 
IMG_9301-640
 
     Photo 5 of 19 — 5603/5613 Rhodes Street — Duplex — $1,148,000 — 1941 sq ft
 

 
IMG_9306-640
 
     Photo 6 of 19 — 2746 East 40th Avenue — Small house (attached garage) — $720,000 — 943 sq ft
 

 
     5494 Dundee Street (old address)
     This development is on an extra large lot.

 
IMG_9291-640
 
     Photo 7 of 19 — 5490/5492 Dundee Street — Duplex — $1,200,000 — 1878 sq ft
 

 
IMG_9293-640
 
     Photo 8 of 19 — 5598 Dundee Street — Small house (attached garage) — $788,000 — 1050 sq ft
 

 



 
Duplex + 2 Small Houses

 
     5500 Dundee Street (old address)
     This development is on an extra large, irregularly shaped lot.

 
IMG_9278-640
 
     Photo 9 of 19 — 5502/5508 Dundee Street — Duplex — $1,299,000 — 2064 sq ft
 

 
IMG_9285-640
 
     Photo 10 of 19 — 5512 Dundee Street — Small house — $950,000 — 1330 sq ft
 

 
IMG_9286-640
 
     Photo 11 of 19 — 5522 Dundee Street — Small house (attached garage) — $850,000 — 1209 sq ft
 

 
     2355 East 41st Avenue (old address)
     This development is on an extra large lot.

 
IMG_9359-640
 
     Photo 12 of 19 — 2359/61 East 41st Avenue — Duplex — $1,165,000 — 1975 sq ft
 

 
IMG_9357-640
 
     Photo 13 of 19 — 23?? East 41st Avenue — Small house — $998,000 — 1560 sq ft
 

 
IMG_9353-640
 
     Photo 14 of 19 — 23?? East 41st Avenue — Small house (attached garage) — $??? — 1100 sq ft
 

 



 
Cluster of Small Houses

 
     2899 East 41st Avenue and 5677 Killarney Street (old addresses)
     This development, named “Killarney Ridge,” consists of 1 duplex and 6 small houses. The site
     consists of 2 assembled wide lots on the southwest corner of Killarney Street and 41st Avenue,
     next to Earles Park. Units are 1230-1557 sq ft. Asking prices ranged $759,900-$899,900+ with
     maintenance fees of $126-$159. A similar development is under construction on the 2 assembled
     lots directly to the north of this site, on Killarney Street.

 
IMG_9259-640
 
     Photo 15 of 19
 

 
IMG_9261-640
 
     Photo 16 of 19
 

 
IMG_9263-640
 
     Photo 17 of 19
 

 
IMG_9272-640
 
     Photo 18 of 19
 

 
IMG_9276-640
 
     Photo 19 of 19
 

All photos taken on morning of 10 April 2016, except for three photos of 2355 East 41st Avenue taken on morning of 27 April 2016.
 

Written by eyeonnorquay

30 May 2016 at 3:50 pm

Duplexes 2013-2015

 
Monitoring the Norquay Plan — Report No. 1  (March 2015)

 
A separate posting of fifteen photos of Norquay duplexes from February 2015 accompanies this evaluation.

 
Introduction

This overall review of the 2010-2013 Norquay Plan starts with residential areas, and focuses on the most prevalent new housing type, the duplex. Remark is added for single-family house, a permitted form which is not new. See note appended below on context for brief description of the Norquay Plan and a listing of aspects yet to be reviewed. The City of Vancouver failed to include in the Norquay Plan any mandate for formal review of the effects and consequences of the mass rezoning.

 
Duplexes

A developer can build duplexes outright anywhere in two of three of Norquay’s residential zones (RT-11 and RM-7, but not Transition). Duplex development can include a secondary suite for each unit but not a laneway house. Some sites in RT-11 may qualify for additional infill small houses. There are no formal design guidelines for duplexes in Norquay. However, regulations govern things like height, yards, site coverage of the building, etc. In Norquay, regulations also call for such features as pitched roofs and main doors that face the street. These regulations can be found in Section 4 of the RT-11 and RM-7 District Schedules at

http://former.vancouver.ca/commsvcs/BYLAWS/zoning/RT-11&%20RT-11N.pdf

and

http://former.vancouver.ca/commsvcs/BYLAWS/zoning/RM-7&RM-7N.pdf

 
Commentary

Since 2013, and as of February 2015, the City of Vancouver has issued 44 development permits for duplexes in Norquay. This is by far the most popular form of development to date in our residential zones. Small developers are attracted by the possibility of building denser housing quickly on a single lot.

In general, duplexes with front/back units are being built on narrow, deep lots and side-by-side units on wider lots. The front yard setback is usually in line with neighbouring houses. Back yards are small. The quality of the design varies considerably.

Unit size ranges from approximately 1200 sq. ft. to 2000 sq. ft., with a median size of 1550 sq. ft. The observed asking price range (not inclusive) is $719,000 to $1,098,000, with a median asking price of $899,000 for each unit.

Photos of 15 duplexes completed in Norquay as of February 2015 can be viewed in a separate posting, along with prices and square footages where available.

 
Single Family Houses

Any residential RT-11 or RM-7 or Transition site in Norquay may be developed outright as a single family dwelling. “Outright” land uses are those that are permitted by the City of Vancouver, provided that all the regulations and provisions of the Zoning and Development Bylaw and the Parking Bylaw are met. The builder does not need to go through a lengthy development application process, where the proposal is evaluated according to formal development guidelines and impact on neighbours is considered. A single family dwelling built in Norquay follows city-wide RS-1 (Single Family Dwelling) regulations. They can be found at

http://former.vancouver.ca/commsvcs/BYLAWS/zoning/RS-1.PDF

 
Commentary

Since Norquay’s new zoning was passed in spring 2013, the City of Vancouver has issued 15 development permits for new single family dwellings. We have not observed any new single family houses being advertised for sale, possibly because these sites are being redeveloped by existing owners.

In addition, we have noticed 3 major renovations of existing single family houses in Norquay since 2013.

 
Context

Note:  Subsequent monitoring reports are anticipated for

	RT-11 (Small House/Duplex) Zone
	RM-7  (Rowhouse/Stacked Townhouse) Zone
	Transition Zone
	Kingsway Development
	Kingsway Public Realm
	Public Benefits
	Comprehensive Analysis

 

In the fall of 2010, Vancouver City Council adopted the Norquay Village Neighbourhood Centre Plan. The plan lays out a “roadmap forward” that is supposed to guide development in Norquay for the next 30 years.

In the spring of 2013, Vancouver City Council adopted new zoning schedules for Norquay. Most of the residential area was rezoned to RT-11 (small house/duplex) or RM-7 (rowhouse/stacked townhouse). A rezoning policy was put in place for the Transition zone (four storey apartments) immediately behind Kingsway.

Specifications for development along Kingsway are part of the 2010 Norquay Plan.

 
norqmap-640
 
     Norquay Village Zoning Map
 

Council also adopted a Public Benefits Strategy and Apartment Transition Area Rezoning Policy for Norquay in spring 2013. This policy identifies the key amenities and services that Norquay can expect to accompany development, and suggests how they should be funded. To date, nothing has been delivered.

Development has begun. The City of Vancouver has no formal process for monitoring the implementation of the Norquay Plan. This series of postings will examine how the Norquay Plan of 2010, the subsequent new zoning schedules of 2013, and the Public Benefits Strategy are being implemented.
 

Written by eyeonnorquay

22 March 2015 at 3:38 pm

15 New Duplexes – Photos

leave a comment »

 
The photos below complement a review of new duplexes built since implementation of Norquay Plan zoning in spring 2013. (Half-duplex price and sq ft data is given as discovered, with no specification attempted for particular side or sub-unit.)

 
IMG_7813
 
     Photo 1 of 15 — 2187 / 2189 East 34th Avenue — $899,800 — 1465 sq ft
 

 
IMG_7837
 
     Photo 2 of 15 — 2457 /2459 Brock Street — $875,000 — 1550 sq ft
 

 
IMG_7838
 
     Photo 3 of 15 — 2463 / 2465 Brock Street — $888,000 — ??? sq ft
 

 
IMG_7816
 
     Photo 4 of 15 — 5444 / 5446 Clarendon Street — $ ??? — ??? sq ft
 

 
IMG_7832
 
     Photo 5 of 15 — 2735 / 2737 Duke Street — $ ??? — ??? sq ft
 

 
IMG_7829
 
     Photo 6 of 15 — 2795 / 2799 Horley Street — $ ??? — ??? sq ft
 

 
IMG_7827
 
     Photo 7 of 15 — 4816 / 4818 Earles Street — $899,000 — 1407 sq ft
 

 
IMG_7826
 
     Photo 8 of 15 — 4888 / 4898 Earles Street — $798,000 — 1420 sq ft
 

 
IMG_7814
 
     Photo 9 of 15 — 5069 / 5071 / 5073 Nanaimo Street — $898,000 — 1558 sq ft
 

 
IMG_7815
 
     Photo 10 of 15 — 5092 / 5094 Nanaimo Street — $798,000 — 1417 sq ft
 

 
IMG_7825
 
     Photo 11 of 15 — 5606 /5608 Rhodes Street — $1,098,000 — 1994 sq ft
 

 
IMG_7835
 
     Photo 12 of 15 — 4833 / 4835 Slocan Street — $853,000 — 1753 sq ft
 

 
IMG_7819
 
     Photo 13 of 15 — 5495 / 5499 Slocan Street — $ ??? — ??? sq ft
 

 
IMG_7820
 
     Photo 14 of 15 — 5551 / 5557 Slocan Street — $1,018,000 — 1960 sq ft
 

 
IMG_7824
 
     Photo 15 of 15 — 5554 (1 & 2) Wales Street — $1,098,000 — 1994 sq ft
 

All photos taken on morning of 19 February 2015.
 

Written by eyeonnorquay

22 March 2015 at 3:37 pm